Tipping: A Restaurant Controversy

June 9, 2017

When it comes to tipping or no-tipping policies in restaurants, there are strong feelings on both sides.

While many restaurants have implemented no tipping policies, others are strong proponents for tipping. Still others aren’t sure which policy is right for their restaurant.

Restaurateurs like Andrew Hoffman want to phase out tipping from restaurants, referring to it as an unhealthy practice. Other stakeholders in the industry, like Kenneth White, are unopposed to the practice of tipping, asserting that it has become part of the dining culture. With the raging controversy on this subject, looking at the pros and cons of tipping will help provide some answers.

Let’s start with the pros. The strongest argument for allowing tipping in a restaurant is the excellent treatment provided to customers, with the tip serving as an incentive. This idea is strongly rooted in the American culture, as most diners see tips as part of the system. In fact, tipping is an age-long practice that dates back to the 18th century.

Employees in such restaurants typically accept lower wages, with the expectation that they will make up for it with the tips they will received. This provides a strong incentive for employees to provide excellent service in the hopes that appreciative customers will be generous with their tips. In the end, the staff can earn far above the minimum wage, while helping create an experience that keeps your customers coming back.

As a restaurant manager, you can also benefit from the tip because many customers make calculate the tip they will give based on a certain percentage of their bill. This motivates servers to upsell the menu in the expectation of a bigger tip. In this way, they are boosting your profits and increasing their own income at the same time.

However, there are limitations to allowing tips in your restaurants, which you must consider from the outset. Tipping can affect the staff retention rate of your restaurant due to the unstable income of the staff. They will be relying on tips which may or may not come. This can push out staff who want a more stable source of livelihood.

Even though tips often boost morale, they can sometimes have the opposite effect. When a server tries hard to please a difficult customer who is impossible to satisfy or who just doesn’t believe in tipping, or when customers choose not to tip because of things completely out of the server’s control (like a mix-up in the kitchen, for example), servers can become frustrated and less motivated.

There are also many different opinions about how tips should be split amongst the different restaurant staff, and this can become a source of resentment if some of your employees feel the tip splitting strategy is not fair. All of these factors can contribute to less motivated, less cheerful staff who will leave sooner and who won’t provide top service to your customers.

As a restaurateur, you are at the liberty of determining the policy in place in your restaurant. Weigh the options and decide which is important to your business growth and sustainability.

It’s a Toast: Why We Love the “Friends” Kitchen

It’s a Toast: Why We Love the “Friends” Kitchen

Welcome to our new series, “Roast and Toast!” Each month we’re going to feature one kitchen we love and one kitchen we hate. It can be from anywhere – a sitcom, a cooking show, a cartoon, a movie, or any other screen you’d see one on! We’re starting off with a toast...

read more
Ready to Open a Second Restaurant Location?

Ready to Open a Second Restaurant Location?

If your current restaurant is booming, it might be time to consider a second location. Congratulations on your current success – you’ve already beaten the odds! Opening a second location can be easier than your first one – you’ve already worked out a lot of the kinks....

read more
The One Product to Boost Convenience Store Sales

The One Product to Boost Convenience Store Sales

Is there one product that can single-handedly make or break the success of your convenience store? A lot of store owners would say no. When they look at their store, they see products coming from hot dish foodservice equipment, shelves, and a variety of categories...

read more
Restaurant Equipment Spotlight: Gas vs. Electric

Restaurant Equipment Spotlight: Gas vs. Electric

Does your Little Rock restaurant use gas or electric restaurant equipment? In all likelihood you made this decision a long time ago, but it’s one that can always be reconsidered. There are benefits to both. If you’re opening a new restaurant location, it’s vital to...

read more
Restaurant Equipment: Self-Ordering Technology

Restaurant Equipment: Self-Ordering Technology

One of the biggest challenges of running a restaurant is keeping up with all the technology and restaurant equipment that is available. You might have thought when you opened your location that you could run things basically the same way for decades.  While they may...

read more
Four Tips to Opening a Successful Restaurant

Four Tips to Opening a Successful Restaurant

Have you been dreaming about bringing your food expertise to the forefront of you life? Many people have thought about opening their own restaurant. Folks don’t follow through for a variety of reasons – money, fear, or simple inertia. You can be different, though. You...

read more
The Case for Timeless Restaurant Décor

The Case for Timeless Restaurant Décor

What’s the newest trend in restaurant décor? Evidently, people are loving “Millennial pink,” and they’re using it for everything. If you’re trying to keep up with what’s hot, you better get some new restaurant supplies right away! And remember, this isn’t just any...

read more
Deep Fry Safely & Efficiently

Deep Fry Safely & Efficiently

When it comes to kitchen equipment, knowing how to use it correctly is vital. Not only does it keep your employees safe, it ensures that the food comes out well and that your equipment last a long time in good condition. Using a deep fryer may seem pretty simple, and...

read more
Should You Buy Closeout Restaurant Supplies?

Should You Buy Closeout Restaurant Supplies?

As a restaurant owner, you, of course, want to save money in any way possible. Restaurant margins are known for being razor-thin, so every dollar counts. Because of this, you might be tempted when you see a closeout deal for restaurant supplies. After all, you can get...

read more
Choosing Environmentally Friendly Restaurant Supplies

Choosing Environmentally Friendly Restaurant Supplies

There’s been a lot of controversy recently about restaurant supplies and how they affect the environment. The current focus is on plastic straws, but the same conversation has been had about Styrofoam and a variety of other materials. Can you choose environmentally...

read more
Restaurant Supplies to Prepare Your Location for Spring

Restaurant Supplies to Prepare Your Location for Spring

In March you can begin to feel warmer weather around the corner here in Little Rock. After all, the groundhog didn’t see its shadow this year, so we’re in for an early spring, right? As you think about how to prepare your restaurant for spring, think about getting the...

read more
Proper Use of Cutting Boards

Proper Use of Cutting Boards

Food safety is vital to every restaurant – consistent inspections make sure of it!  Unfortunately, the day-to-day operations can sometimes mean that safety falls through the cracks. One thing that can get overlooked in a busy kitchen is the safe use of cutting boards....

read more
Four Myths About Food Trucks

Four Myths About Food Trucks

You probably know that the food truck industry is booming – it’s grown by 7.3% in the last five years and shows no signs of slowing down. That makes it an attractive industry for anyone interested in serving food – from established restaurants to new entrepreneurs....

read more