Tipping: A Restaurant Controversy

June 9, 2017

When it comes to tipping or no-tipping policies in restaurants, there are strong feelings on both sides.

While many restaurants have implemented no tipping policies, others are strong proponents for tipping. Still others aren’t sure which policy is right for their restaurant.

Restaurateurs like Andrew Hoffman want to phase out tipping from restaurants, referring to it as an unhealthy practice. Other stakeholders in the industry, like Kenneth White, are unopposed to the practice of tipping, asserting that it has become part of the dining culture. With the raging controversy on this subject, looking at the pros and cons of tipping will help provide some answers.

Let’s start with the pros. The strongest argument for allowing tipping in a restaurant is the excellent treatment provided to customers, with the tip serving as an incentive. This idea is strongly rooted in the American culture, as most diners see tips as part of the system. In fact, tipping is an age-long practice that dates back to the 18th century.

Employees in such restaurants typically accept lower wages, with the expectation that they will make up for it with the tips they will received. This provides a strong incentive for employees to provide excellent service in the hopes that appreciative customers will be generous with their tips. In the end, the staff can earn far above the minimum wage, while helping create an experience that keeps your customers coming back.

As a restaurant manager, you can also benefit from the tip because many customers make calculate the tip they will give based on a certain percentage of their bill. This motivates servers to upsell the menu in the expectation of a bigger tip. In this way, they are boosting your profits and increasing their own income at the same time.

However, there are limitations to allowing tips in your restaurants, which you must consider from the outset. Tipping can affect the staff retention rate of your restaurant due to the unstable income of the staff. They will be relying on tips which may or may not come. This can push out staff who want a more stable source of livelihood.

Even though tips often boost morale, they can sometimes have the opposite effect. When a server tries hard to please a difficult customer who is impossible to satisfy or who just doesn’t believe in tipping, or when customers choose not to tip because of things completely out of the server’s control (like a mix-up in the kitchen, for example), servers can become frustrated and less motivated.

There are also many different opinions about how tips should be split amongst the different restaurant staff, and this can become a source of resentment if some of your employees feel the tip splitting strategy is not fair. All of these factors can contribute to less motivated, less cheerful staff who will leave sooner and who won’t provide top service to your customers.

As a restaurateur, you are at the liberty of determining the policy in place in your restaurant. Weigh the options and decide which is important to your business growth and sustainability.

What’s in a Cooking Pot, How to Choose the Right One?

What’s in a Cooking Pot, How to Choose the Right One?

As a restaurant owner, your cooking needs might vary. Did you know that a good quality pot can greatly improve your cooking experience, while also improving the quality of your cooking? This cooking equipment is a very important one that cannot be done away with...

read more
Top Restaurant Technology Trends in 2018

Top Restaurant Technology Trends in 2018

When looking to buy restaurant supplies, you want to be on the leading edge of technology trends. This will keep your kitchen running smoothly.  Let’s take a look at some of the most recent trends in restaurant supplies technology. 1. New Payment Options Who would...

read more
5 Different Ice Shapes and Why You Should Care About Them

5 Different Ice Shapes and Why You Should Care About Them

Ice makers are very popular in the restaurant and foodservice community because they eliminate the need to buy ice every day. And of course, adding an ice maker to your collection of foodservice equipment means you will always have ice on hand when you need it. An...

read more
Choosing the Right Milk Cooler: Cold Wall or Forced Air?

Choosing the Right Milk Cooler: Cold Wall or Forced Air?

In a restaurant, milk is an essential to have on hand for coffee and other café-style beverages, for serving with kids’ meals, and as a key ingredient in many recipes. Keeping your milk properly chilled can be difficult without the proper restaurant equipment....

read more
How to Choose Your Next Commercial Meat Smoker

How to Choose Your Next Commercial Meat Smoker

The movies that connect with us on a personal level are the ones that linger in our memories forever. Anyone who has used a commercial meat smoker knows that they have a huge influence on the taste of a meal. You need to have just the right kitchen equipment to get a...

read more
Are High Speed Ovens Too Good to be True?

Are High Speed Ovens Too Good to be True?

You might have heard a few of the bold claims that foodservice equipment manufacturers have been making about high speed ovens, but they can’t be possible, right? Cooking three times as faster as regular ovens?  Five times as fast?  Fifteen times as fast?  It may seem...

read more
Choosing the Right Food Storage Containers for Your Restaurant

Choosing the Right Food Storage Containers for Your Restaurant

Choosing the right kitchen supplies will make a difference in your restaurant. Whether it is heavy duty kitchen equipment or food storage containers, each piece of equipment plays its own important role. Today, we are going to talk about how to choose the right food...

read more
Tipton’s Guide to Perfect Poultry Trussing

Tipton’s Guide to Perfect Poultry Trussing

Do you ever truss birds in your commercial kitchen? Trussing is a fantastic cooking technique because it makes poultry cook faster, look more attractive and taste better. If your commercial kitchen prepares poultry, you don’t want to miss these trussing tips. Trussing...

read more
How to Eliminate Excess Condensation in Your Kitchen

How to Eliminate Excess Condensation in Your Kitchen

Is your commercial kitchen getting steamy? If so, you could have more than just an uncomfortable working environment on your hands. Excess moisture in your commercial kitchen can result in the corrosion of equipment, the development of mold, and even damage to your...

read more
The DIY Guide to Your Restaurant’s Own Garden

The DIY Guide to Your Restaurant’s Own Garden

Stocking your restaurant supply with your own home-grown herbs and produce can truly bring your dishes to life. When it comes to food, everyone knows there’s nothing like homemade and home-grown. Having your own culinary garden, however large or small, can help you...

read more
5 Reasons a Meat Grinder Will Set Your Burgers Apart

5 Reasons a Meat Grinder Will Set Your Burgers Apart

The more you do to prepare your foods in-house with the right kitchen equipment, the fresher and more flavorful your dishes become. There are all sorts of restaurants offering fast-food style burgers, but some diners are looking for the real deal. A fresh, juicy...

read more
Pest Preventions to Implement in Your Commercial Kitchen

Pest Preventions to Implement in Your Commercial Kitchen

Restaurant pests: it’s something that few people want to think about. Like it or not, pest management is an essential consideration for every commercial kitchen. Offering food, shelter and water, the unprepared commercial kitchen naturally provides everything pests...

read more
Choosing the Right Material for Your Cooking Equipment

Choosing the Right Material for Your Cooking Equipment

Kitchens are very unique to their chef. Just like a car mechanic has a toolbox unique to them, so is the cooking equipment in a kitchen. And over time, the same cooking equipment become a natural extension of the chef. What tools are you using in your kitchen? It...

read more